data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d5e14/d5e149bdf5a30c98c258b00fff6dd3725cb471c9" alt="Law Self logo"
History
and Overview of the FDA
Problems
of contamination in food supplies have plagued consumers for as long as the
concept of shared resources has existed. Toxicity or lack of effectiveness have
been liabilities in the development of medicinal products throughout recorded
history. From Hippocrates’ use of wine covered with fig leaves to treat wounds
to the introduction of artificial skin, from chewing on willow bark to treat
fever to genetically-targeted pharmaceuticals, the history of health care is
brimming with stories of spectacular successes and catastrophic failures.
In the
US and worldwide, food and drug safety issues have been addressed by a series
of laws enacted throughout the last century. Enforcement of these laws is the
primary role of the US Food and Drug Administration, commonly referred to as
the FDA. The FDA is most commonly thought of in the context of approval of new
drugs. Its mandate, however, actually extends far beyond pharmaceuticals. It is
responsible for approval and oversight of a broad range of products including
food, drugs, medical devices, radiation-emitting products, vaccines, blood and
biologicals, veterinary products, cosmetics, and tobacco products. This
presentation will briefly review the origin and evolution of this body into the
important governmental agency that exists today.
The
Department of Agriculture was established in 1862 by President Abraham Lincoln
and immediately set out to address a myriad of issues related to food production
and safety. As it became apparent that the problem of food adulteration was
becoming more and more widespread, a special division of the Department of
Agriculture- the Bureau of Chemistry- was charged with enforcing a ground-breaking
statute known as the Federal Food and Drugs Act of 1906. The regulatory wing of
the Bureau of Chemistry saw its responsibilities and authority evolve, and it
ultimately became known as the Food and Drug Administration. In 1940, the FDA
was removed from the Department of Agriculture and, after transitions through
the Federal Security Agency and the Public Health Service of the Department of
Health, Education and Welfare, today’s FDA is a division of the US Department
of Health and Human Services.
Prior
to the creation of the FDA and its antecedents, control of adulterated and
misbranded foods and of drugs was haphazard, at best. State and local
governments loosely and, often ineffectively, monitored food and drug
production and claims of effectiveness for medicinal products. More often, the
publication of information related to these topics and the resulting reactions
of the public was left to individuals or citizen groups. Thus, the American
Medical Association, the American Pharmaceutical Association, and journalists
and authors were at the forefront of the investigation of these critical
problems. A famous example was the publication of Upton Sinclair’s novel, The
Jungle, which highlighted health violations and unsanitary practices in the
American meatpacking industry, and which led to meaningful reforms.
Similarly,
a tragic experience with a popular “wonder drug” exposed the lack of
coordinated oversight in the pharmaceutical realm and spurred public outcry and
legislative action. Sulfanilamide[1][2] was a widely used and
highly effective treatment for streptococcal infections. It had been used
safely in tablet and capsule forms, with impressive curative effects, for
almost three decades. In an effort to satisfy a regional demand for a liquid
form of the medicine, a new formulation was developed in which the drug powder
was dissolved in diethylene glycol, the unpleasant taste was masked with a
flavoring agent, and this new “Sulfanilamide Elixir” was quickly dispatched, in
September of 1937, to eagerly awaiting clinics throughout various sections of
the country. Within weeks, there was reported a sudden rash of deaths in
patients to whom this elixir was administered. In October and November of 1937,
the drug was implicated in the deaths of more than 100 people in 15 states.
Once the association to Sulfanilamide Elixir was identified, scores of FDA
agents and others were sent out to recover the distributed medicine. Although
diethylene glycol was commonly used as an antifreeze, its toxicity in humans
was not yet widely known. Since safety testing was not required for drug
formulations, the poisonous effects of this supposedly life-saving elixir came
as a horrifying surprise. Public demands following this event precipitated the
enactment of the 1938 Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act that provided for a rigorous
system of animal testing and controls in the development and approval of new
drugs and formulations.
Numerous
amendments to the original Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act, and additional related
legislation in subsequent decades, have dramatically expanded the authority of
the FDA to enforce regulations in a very broad arena. Today, FDA devises and
enforces policies related to the development, testing, manufacturing, and
marketing of a diverse range of food and health-related entities, including the
following:
· - Testing insulin and antibiotics
· - Regulation of chemical pesticides
· - Regulation of food and color additives
· - Distinction between prescription and non-prescription
medications
· - Regulation of drug efficacy
· - Ensuring good manufacturing practices
· - Control of prescription drug advertising
· - Regulation of
therapeutic agents of biological origin
· - Oversight of nutrition labeling
In
recent years, consumer demand and political pressures have led to FDA efforts
to accelerate drug approval timelines, particularly for orphan drugs (for rare
diseases) and for treatment of new illnesses, such as AIDS. FDA has responded
to the needs of both patients and researchers by improving techniques for the
development and testing of new drugs and drug formulations, as well as by extending
patent protections to allow for time-consuming testing and approval processes. It
has also modified the review process for generic versions of drugs in order to
encourage and facilitate the development of lower-cost alternatives to
brand-name products.
The
over-arching responsibility of the FDA is to ensure, as far as possible, that
the foods and drugs that we consume are safe and, in the case of pharmaceuticals
and other medical products, will have a positive impact in the treatment of a
medical condition. However, while lack of efficacy is a significant disqualifying
factor for any drug being brought to the market, the basic guiding principle, first
and foremost, is the same as that stated in the Hippocratic Oath that is sworn
to by newly graduated physicians: “first, do no harm”.
[1] US Department
of Heatlh and Human Services / US FDA website
[2]
Taste of Raspberries, Taste of Death, The 1937 Elixir Sulfanilamide Incident,
Carol Ballentine, FDA Consumer Magazine, June 1981