Other Forms of Damages
See Also:
Terms:Nominal Damages: Liquidated Damages: Punitive Damages: |
In addition to the basic measure of damages, there are several other measures of damages:
- nominal damages,
- liquidated damages and,
- punitive damages.
Nominal Damages
Nominal damages are token damages whose purpose is only to acknowledge that the injured party has been injured. For example:
Exotic Elixirs is a fledgling juice company that is trying to get its business off the ground. Exotic orders expensive juicing machinery from AgraTech and signs contracts with several different fruit growers to supply them with ingredients. AgraTech fails to deliver the machinery and, because Exotic cannot meet its demands, Exotic’s customers take their business elsewhere. As a result, Exotic goes out of business three months after opening. If Exotic sues AgraTech for lost profits and the court cannot determine with reasonable certainty what those lost profits were, it is likely that nominal damages, of perhaps $1 will be awarded as a token acknowledgement that Exotic was harmed.
Liquidated Damages
Liquidated damages are damage amounts that are negotiated by the parties beforehand so that, in the event of a breach, the contract itself states how much damages the injured party can recover. For example:
Ramon Garcia and the Boston Red Sox enter into a contract under which Garcia agrees to play for the team for one year and the team agrees to pay Garcia $500,000. The contract also says that if the Red Sox breach the contract, they will be liable for $100,000 in damages. The $100,000 in damages provided for in the contract in the event of a breach are liquidated damages.
In order for a provision that establishes damages to be valid, it must meet two requirements.
First, at the time the contract is made, actual damages must be difficult to calculate and, second, the amount of damages established in the contract must be a reasonable forecast of what damages would have been. For example:
Exotic Elixirs is a fledgling juice company that is trying to get its business off the ground. Exotic orders expensive juicing machinery from AgraTech and, under the contract, AgraTech agrees to be pay Exotic $50,000 in damages if AgraTech breaches the contract. AgraTech fails to deliver the machinery and, because Exotic cannot meet its demands, Exotic’s customers take their business elsewhere. In this case, liquidated damages will likely be upheld. First, as we said earlier, lost profits of a new business are very difficult to calculate and so, the first element required for validating liquidated damages is met. Therefore, if the court determines that $50,000 was a reasonable forecast of the damages Elixir would suffer as a result of the breach, the liquidated damages clause would be valid and AgraTech would be liable for the $50,000.
Punitive Damages
The general rule is that an injured party cannot recover punitive damages for breach of contract. See
However, there are two exceptions to this rule. The first exception involves torts in that, if the action breaching the contract is a tort in and of itself, punitive damages can be recovered. The second exception involves bad faith, in that punitive damages can be recovered for a breach done in bad faith.